A Win for Energy Service Providers in Direct Access Proceeding

On December 1, 2011, the California Public Utilities Commission unanimously approved a decision in its proceeding to authorize an increase in Direct Access retail electric service.

The decision was a victory for Commercial Energy of California, represented by Goodin MacBride partner Michael Day, and other Energy Service Providers (ESPs) and their retail energy customers. Decision 11-12-018 modified the pricing of non-bypassable surcharges paid by customers who purchase their energy from ESPs and pay distribution and transmission charges to the utilities, such as PG&E.

These modifications will reduce the surcharges for Direct Access customers, better reflect the value of renewable resources, and make the competitive retail energy market more viable. In addition, the Commission found in favor of Commercial Energy and the other ESPs and flatly rejected a proposal by PG&E and Southern California Edison to force ESPs representing larger commercial and industrial customers to comply with complex and expensive financial security requirements that would make Direct Access potentially uneconomic for both ESPs and their customers.

Read the press release

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin


As of October 1, 2021, the law firm of Goodin, MacBride, Squeri & Day, LLP has dissolved its partnership. In order to reach any of the firm’s professionals in their current practices, please contact them through the information found below.

The following are all practicing as part of Downey Brand LLP, in its San Francisco office:

Thomas J. MacBride, Jr.
James D. Squeri
Michael B. Day
Brian T. Cragg
Megan J. Somogyi
Nirvesh Sikand

Robert A. Goodin and Keith E. Johnson are continuing their commercial litigation practice as The Law Offices of Robert A. Goodin.  They may be reached at:

John L. Clark is now working as a solo practitioner, and can be reached at: